Arbitration
Sierra Leone laws recognise arbitration as a means of dispute resolution between private parties in Commercial and Civil transactions. The new Arbitration Act 2022 [4] which repealed and replaced the Arbitration Act Chapter 25 (CAP 25) of the laws of Sierra Leone 1960 applies to domestic and international arbitrations with a seat in Sierra Leone and also contains provisions governing arbitrations to which the Government of Sierra Leone is a party. It applies to all arbitrations commenced on or after 22 September 2022 (unless the parties have agreed otherwise). The 2022 Act seeks to clarify, modernise and improve the law relating to arbitrations and arbitral awards. It provides a comprehensive arbitration framework which is in line with international standards and based on a sound set of guiding principles. The Act includes Arbitration Rules, which apply to domestic arbitrations in Sierra Leone, subject to any modifications that parties may agree. If the Arbitration Rules conflict with the 2022 Act, the provisions of the 2022 Act will prevail.
Court of Appeal
Section 128(1) of the 1991 Constitution of Sierra Leone provides that the Court of Appeal shall consist of (i) the Chief Justice, (ii) not less than seven Justices of the Court of Appeal and (iii) such other Justices of the superior court of the Sierra Leone judicature as the Chief Justice may determine.
Section 128(2) provides that the Court of Appeal shall be duly constituted by any three Court of Appeal judges. However, a single Justice of the Court of Appeal may exercise any power vested in the Court of Appeal not involving the decision on any cause or matter before the Court of Appeal save:
in criminal matters, if any such Justice refuses or grants an application in exercise of any such power, any such person affected thereby shall be entitled to have the application determined by the Court of Appeal as duly constituted; and
in civil matters, any order, direction or decision made or given in pursuant to the power conferred by the provision may be varied, discharged or reversed by the Court of Appeal as duly constituted.
High Court
The Sierra Leone Constitution provides that the High Court shall consist of (i) the Chief Justice, (ii) not less than nine High Court judges and (iii) such other judges of the superior court of the Sierra Leone judicature as the Chief Justice may determine. The High Court shall be duly constituted by any one judge of the High Court sitting with a jury (Constitution, section 131(2)).
The High Court has supervisory jurisdiction over all inferior traditional Courts in Sierra Leone and any adjudicating authority. In the exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction it has the power to issue directions, writs, and orders.
Effectiveness of the court system
The Judiciary is considered by many as not being independent and that it remains subject to manipulations and corruption. It is seen by many citizens as slow and ineffective to resolve disputes.
Enforcement of arbitral awards
The Arbitration Act 2022 governs the enforcement of arbitral awards.
Enforcement of foreign judgments
The New York Convention (NYC) to which Sierra Leone is a signatory, upholds arbitral agreements and facilitates the enforcement of foreign arbitral awards in 88% of the world's countries. Section 67 of the Arbitration Act 2022 Act specifically implements the NYC, with the effect that an arbitral award made outside Sierra Leone may benefit from the NYC enforcement regime if the following three conditions are met:
- Reciprocity: the country in which the arbitral award was made is party to the NYC;
- Commerciality: the underlying dispute arises out of a legal relationship considered "commercial" under Sierra Leone law; and
- Non-Retroactivity: the relevant arbitration agreement and award were respectively concluded and rendered after the date of Sierra Leone's accession to the NYC (i.e. after 28 October 2020). See more here.
Section 81 confirms that foreign awards which are not enforceable under the NYC will be governed by the Foreign Judgments (Reciprocal Enforcement) Act 1960.This provides a fallback provision, should Section 67 not apply. However, it should be noted that the 1960 Act requires the relevant country to have a bilateral or reciprocal enforcement treaty with Sierra Leone. If this is not the case, parties wishing to enforce a foreign award will only have resort to the enforcement regime under Sections 65-66. Sections 65-66 additionally set out a self-contained, but expansive, enforcement regime applicable to domestic and foreign awards and are reflective of international standards.
Judiciary
Section 135 of the Constitution entrusts the appointment of the Chief Justice and other judges of the higher courts of the judicature of Sierra Leone on the President with the approval of the Judicial and Legal Services Commission and subject to the approval of Parliament.
Magistrates Court
The Magistrates Court is the primary inferior court of judicature in Sierra Leone. Sierra Leone was divided into Judicial Districts pursuant to The Courts Act, 1965 (as amended) [5]. Section 4 of the Courts Act provides that every Judicial District shall have a Magistrates Court.
Magistrates Courts have limited jurisdiction. Subject to their limitations, Section 8 of the Courts Act 1965 provides that the Magistrates Court shall have the jurisdiction to do all lawful acts necessary to enquire into, and dispose of, or to hear and determine all civil and criminal matters arising within the district, area, or transferred to the relevant Magistrates Court by the High Court.
Supreme Court
The Supreme Court sits at the top of the Sierra Leone court hierarchy. Section 121(1) of the Sierra Leone Constitution provides that the Supreme Court shall consist of (i) the Chief Justice, (ii) not less than four Justices of Supreme Court and (iii) such other Justices of the superior court of the Sierra Leone judicature or of the superior courts of any state operating a body of law similar to Sierra Leone.
The Coram of the Supreme Court is three justices. The Supreme Court is the final Court of Appeal in Sierra Leone and as such, appellate and other jurisdiction may be conferred upon it by the Constitution or any other law.